by Rob Gonsalves
You donâ€™t truly appreciate a standard film technique used competently until youâ€™ve seen it used ineptly.Take flashbacks. Used well, they can change up or unify a movieâ€™s tone as well as strengthening theme and character, and they do this without confusing the audience. And then you have a film like Lutfu Emre Cicekâ€™s Naciye (soon to get a limited release after some festival activity last fall), which almost seems to be a lesson in how to use flashbacks to baffle the viewer and for no other purpose. This gory Turkish horror film, whose only lively bits are clumsily-realized murders, also pads itself out egregiously in the telling of a fairly simple tale: A woman, the eponymous Naciye (Derya Alabora), has been illegally living in a house for years, and when anyone threatens to dislodge her, she goes berserk.
"Another dull calling card in the horror genre."
Leaving aside the perhaps overly literal question of how Naciyeâ€™s squatting and killing have gone unnoticed by the cops for decades, we follow a young couple â€” a pregnant woman and her boyfriend â€” as they come to live in the home, which they donâ€™t realize is occupied. This couple, and especially the woman, are obnoxiously miserable, so we donâ€™t care very much whether they live or die. The suspicion arises that the script makes the woman pregnant so weâ€™ll care about the fetus, at least. The woman walks around the house endlessly, noticing details that indicate someone else has lived there recently and may still live there. Meanwhile, Naciye lurks in the home, sometimes aided by a mysterious man, or is it two men?
The flashbacks, dumped into the narrative with no particular motivating incident, are supposed to clarify things but end up muddying them considerably. We see Naciye as a girl whose mom, I guess, cleaned the house for a man who, I guess, routinely raped her. This trauma led to Naciye staying in the home forever, and there are other familial twists. None of which have much relevance to the main narrative. About the only point of interest is the movieâ€™s critique of its cultureâ€™s misogyny, a concern that links it to a far better Turkish film, the crude but harsh and elemental Yol. The pregnant womanâ€™s boyfriend seems to try on sexist attitudes for size, maybe because he remembers his father or even grandfather saying the same things. The movie isnâ€™t sexist: we see here, in a horror/thriller context, how hatred of women blooms out of fear of them. The men here have no power â€” the women carry life (literally) or death.
But that makes Naciye sound so much more interesting than it is. Slow and repetitive, with the flashbacks done in the same bland, unemphatic style as the contemporary scenes, the movie feeds a few people to Naciye to stab full of holes, then to bury (is this place so secluded that nobody notices corpses being rolled into graves in broad daylight?). The film runs only 78 minutes but feels twice as long, and seems to have just enough story for a film half as long. Lutfu Emre Cicek does have an eye; the widescreen compositions speak elegantly of isolation. But the story heâ€™s telling with those images overstays its welcome and outlives our patience.Itâ€™s yet another calling-card film like "It Follows," not born of the genuine fear and obsession that distinguish real horror, but out of a desire to make something â€ścoolâ€ť inspired by oneâ€™s betters.
link directly to this review at http://www.hollywoodbitchslap.com/review.php?movie=30365&reviewer=416
originally posted: 03/21/16 13:29:20