User Comments

11/04/15 David Hollingsworth Amazing film! 7/31/08 Ramone Haynes' academic approach doesn't neglect real emotion here 6/20/07 fools♫gold Almost as SHOCKINGLY flawless as "Yes." 5/31/07 Anton Though the story was a bit flat, Julianne gives another incredible performance. 12/27/06 Rob H Felt like an academic exercise or parody. Could not get into it. 10/26/06 Matt H. Flawless cinematography, really amazing, however I do believe the story was a bit flat. 8/16/06 anthonyuk when will the oscars recognize julianne moore as one of the best ever 1/02/06 Daveman Hammy, even by melodrama standards. 6/01/05 JFK great actings, great plot. Bad ending 12/11/04 Charlene Javier Julianne Moore was robbed! 9/25/04 NJ Cup Winner 95-00-03 Not as good as I had hoped, tho I respect Moore & Dennis a lot 10/04/03 Darryl Seen all this before. Just maybe not in 1957 Hartford. Nothing special. J. Moore is good. 10/01/03 Jinnvisible People have Gay and Interracial love problems-- YES WE KNOW-beautifull photography though 9/11/03 filmfatale Excellent and riveting movie - Julianne did a great job! 8/27/03 Chris The film's not perfect but very good none the less. The actors were all excellent. 8/14/03 Ayla much better than expected 7/24/03 Léo parent I LOVE THIS MOVIE I THINK IT,A GREAT MOVIE 6/02/03 brentley The acting, the cinematography, the set design, everything - was all top notch. 5/30/03 Jack Sommersby Familiar ideas directed and performed with flair and power. A wonderful film. 5/25/03 Gil Carlson Hopelessly over rated and highly improbable 5/11/03 Artist Freak Not as aweomse as I thought it would be. Nice cinematography tho. 4/19/03 Boo Splendid 4/05/03 gay man who's sirk 3/22/03 Kyle Not bad. Didn't meet my expectations, though... 3/19/03 regy A quiet gem of a movie. 3/04/03 James Renwick Touching and moving motion picture. Society is still like in som many ways 2/21/03 Jim the movie geek Slow and unreal in parts, but some powerful bits. 2/13/03 Andrew Carden Excellent film, with great performances. Kudos To Julianne Moore 2/12/03 Joe Tackled these subjects poorly, go rent a Sirk film instead 2/12/03 kz Cinema at its Best 2/12/03 alien assassin If you don't like this, dust off your collection of "happy days" videos. 1/10/03 Goofy Maxwell *sniff* The style is just so beautiful. *sniff* Disillusionment is oh so painful. 12/31/02 Mitchell Morris It's not a movie, it's something better—a "picture." 12/25/02 Marshall Among the 21st century's first classic films. 12/25/02 gg excellent but a bit overstated; technical mastery of late 1950's look is worth going for. 12/23/02 Donna Horrendous propoganda in which no character is remotely close to the 50's. 12/23/02 anna an incredibly artistic piece of work 12/22/02 laura This film is so heavy handed and lacking in subtlety, it's offensive. I'm shocked as well. 12/21/02 take1 Very enjoyable 12/21/02 RS This could and should have been a good film. It wasn't. 12/18/02 geekLove disturbed. Not a good date movie = the husband (me) turns gay, wife (date) loves gardener. 12/17/02 steve interesting film for those that love "film," but honestly, it left me feeling cold. 12/16/02 Cory Phaeus Moore and Quaid's "acting" is so patently phony, I am astounded the "critics" loved them. 12/16/02 This Charming Man perfect period piece - excellent acting 12/16/02 Stephen Essential viewing 12/15/02 john Score detracts, attempts at saluting sirk distracts, story is weak 12/14/02 Mike G Julianne Moore's acting and the set design is amazing! 12/12/02 VINCENT LOCASCIO THIS FILM SHOWCASES DENNIS QUAID'S AMAZING ACTING ABILITIES BUT JULIANNE MOORE IS THE STAR. 12/10/02 renegade mike the struggle to achieve in atmosphere got in the way of a really compelling story 12/09/02 AgainstTheGrain This movie was an academic exercise. Save money, rent a Douglas Sirk movie! 12/08/02 Flora P. Re establishes racial boundaries, Negro as spiritual help for troubled white woman 12/07/02 David Hogan Stunning in every respect, and a movie that makes me understand why I love movies. 12/06/02 Suzz beautiful looking film; fine performances; but flat and uninvolving 11/25/02 marzio arigoni@rtsi.ch What a nice surprise: good film, superb cinematography, Julianne Moore and Dennis Quaid sim 11/20/02 Kenmeister Well-made, well -acted melodrama. The only part that rings false is Raymond. 11/09/02 Ariya Best film of the year

IF YOU'VE SEEN THIS FILM, RATE IT! Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks! Your Name: Your Comments: Your Location: (state/province/country) Your Rating: Select a rating from the list: 5 STARS - Awesome 4 STARS - Worth A Look 3 STARS - Just Average 2 STARS - Pretty Crappy 1 STAR - Sucks