User Comments

7/17/10 Flounder One of my all-time favorite films. Intelligent and emotionally poignant. 1/15/10 Diarmuid Hickey Wonderful. 7/02/09 cindy Nothing funny here, this movie just plain sucked. BORING!!! 11/20/08 Shaun Wallner Interesting Movie! 10/04/08 Lenny Zane Kate Winslet's Oscar nomination for this tripe may be a sign of the end of civilization. 6/09/08 PAUL SHORTT ODD BUT COMPELLING 5/11/08 jordan unforgettable imagery and beautifully crafted. everything works wonderfully. a fav 4sure 1/12/08 R.W.Welch Highly original but overly fragmented. B- 12/15/07 LuLu One of the best movies ever made!!!!! 8/02/07 Me This really sucks.. boring and predictable 6/23/07 VIVEK KRISHNAN SUPERB, THE BEST FILM IN A DECADE 6/15/07 Danielle Ophelia Most movies make me hate myself in the morning. Not this one. 6/03/07 Gary of Winnipeg A very stirring movie but not manipulative 5/12/07 the t-dawg Just Super-Awesome-Tacular 4/08/07 H.M. Anyone who doesn't like this movie is an idiot. (I'm looking at you, one-star guys.) 4/04/07 fools♫gold Not as good or as bad as people say (to me, anyway). Dream-like, and it does it right. 2/15/07 Coenie Best performance by the brilliant Ms Winslet....EVER! 12/23/06 David Pollastrini a bit slow in places but still good 12/22/06 Bill Lambertson Timeless Beauty. Astonishing. 11/28/06 Stanley Thai One of the weirdest, imaginative, best, romance ever! 11/25/06 Jason of Essex Carrey has more than redeemed himself; Winslet is superb. Sad, surreal, beautiful and lol. 11/15/06 Brian O'Neill A phenomenally creative, affecting, unpredictable, fevered dream of a movie. Adored it. 11/03/06 Courtney This film is amazing, truly touching 8/14/06 nathan one of this decades best and most original films 7/12/06 Agent Sands Deserving of every bit of praise it has gotten. 6/06/06 Dave Webber I hatedthis - w-w-a-a-a-y-y-y-y-y too pretentious. 4/30/06 Doug Seriously, HBS needs to bring back the 'Fucking Awesome' rating; 'Awesome' doesn't do. 4/20/06 Diamond This movie is amazing, beautiful, funny, witty, and heart catching... MUST SEE. 3/31/06 Anthony Feor Carrey has hit rock bottom 3/20/06 kerry god does this movie suck 1/04/06 Andrew Cheung After the 6th viewing, the ending is so perfect it still gives me chills 12/26/05 Sammu i don't use to leave a movie theatre before the end of the movie, but this one... blaghr!!! 12/12/05 cooler Winslet still can't act and this movie sucks.BORINGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 12/01/05 Tara I was shocked by how good this movie was. The previews didn't do it justice. 11/15/05 noops show it any mental hospital 11/13/05 Jason Marjoram wikid awsome 10/10/05 Agent Sands Kaufman is so brilliant that he makes u follow his own train of thought during the story. 9/24/05 D Buckley Kind of touching. 8/17/05 Stephen Beautiful and deep without being preachy... well worth your time. 8/05/05 Zack Charlie Kaufman's best screenplay 8/04/05 Gabriel Ruzin heartbreaking and incredible; one of my very favorite 7/25/05 Eric Rollins The French will love this. Unfortunately I'm not decadent enough. 7/22/05 Bad Critic Finally, a good Jim Carrey movie. Well, there was The Cable Guy. I guess I take that back. 7/07/05 delli Great, but i want to see it. 6/29/05 Chris The best movie of this decade, no doubt about it. 6/27/05 R once again, kaufman misses the "comedy" mark, but for the better. he got lucky, THIS time. 5/16/05 E-FUNK Absolutely floored by this film. Gets better and better every viewing. 5/05/05 Regis Best movie of 2004. 5/01/05 dee smith aweful 5/01/05 ed.williams Great movie. Jim Carrey is becoming a great actor...possible another Robin Williams 4/22/05 akram One of the worst movies I have ever seen. 3/29/05 Regis Malone One of the best movies of the 21st century, if not the best. 3/25/05 Mike Best movie of 2004. No, make that the last five years. At least. 3/25/05 MaryBeth Isaac Good - thought provoking; insightful. Very unique storyline. Kate Winslet was perfect 3/24/05 dwarzel Hopefully no more talking out of his backside for Carrey 3/23/05 Michael Lloyd unlike any other film, great cast, great writing, daringly original 3/09/05 jeff beautiful movie!!! very touching. 3/01/05 Taylor Fladgate A masterpiece...blows your mind... 2/17/05 Naka TYPING IN CAPS DOES NOT EXEMPT YOU FROM BEING A MORON WILLIAM. 2/14/05 Angela Saunders Very different movie, unique! 2/14/05 ELI You suck William! :) one of the best movies of the year 1/28/05 WILLIAM LONGWORTH FELL ASLEEP DURING IT, JIM CAREY SHOULD ONLY DO FUNNY MOVIES. 1/25/05 Mark the best film of 2004 1/24/05 Shawn jim carrey is great. great movie 1/19/05 lindy03 This is a great film! 1/15/05 Charlene Javier Brilliant! Bravo! 1/14/05 Dara Elizabeth Van This film has made me look at life from a new perspective. Kate Winslet's BEST EVER!!! 1/12/05 Tom Benton Easily the best film of 2004, and one of the best ever made. 1/11/05 HL Twilight Zone?..Love Story?..Agree With TFH 'bout Kate. 1/07/05 Martin Took some effort, but well worth it. 1/04/05 Echo a lovestory with a twist. now my alltime favorite 1/03/05 Abbath Very well made and written. Best of 2004. 1/03/05 Max An aquired taste. 12/29/04 Debra Sherman even made my nonemotional boyfriend sit up and take notice 12/20/04 ELI Best movie in 2004! :) 12/13/04 Tiffany Faye Hawthorne What Golden Globe idiots mistook this for a decent movie???? Kate Winslut sucks!!!!! 12/12/04 AlbieOne Check it out,,, 12/11/04 Charlene Javier Excellent! Kate Winslet deserves an Oscar! 12/11/04 Jerry Very original. The best movie I've seen in 2004 12/10/04 y2mckay vastly overrated, although Carrey gives a surprisingly good dramatic performance 12/07/04 Lily To date, one of the best movies I have seen......A poignancyso pure and lethal 12/02/04 Film Student Excellent movie, great subtle effects. See it. 11/30/04 lolalaloca13 One of my top 5 fave films now! 11/27/04 Matt F. Probably the best movie i've seen this year 11/22/04 doinkie Stunning, thought provoking and brilliant. Best pic of 04 11/22/04 Peter Scadding Slow to start with then the twists and turns kick in, marvellous film 11/21/04 Jim Compelling psychological fairy tale shows how we forget good memories when things go bad. 11/21/04 David Best movie of the year. 11/20/04 Abbath A beautiful story filled with genuine emotion delievered in the most unique fashion. 11/18/04 Jennifer I cannot get this movie out of my head, it's amazing! 11/17/04 Ry Predictable and a waste of time. 11/17/04 Jews for Hitler Right on the mark with toxic relationships. 11/13/04 Nadia Fantastic. I loved it. 11/07/04 Phil M. Aficionado Glad I saw it; innovative, well made, but too much hocum for my tastes 11/05/04 Sara You're missing out if you don't see this. 11/03/04 Alissa Lubanski This movie is a piece of shit. 10/31/04 Monster W. Kung Frankly, I expected better than this. Not bad, but far from great. 10/29/04 Elise WOW, best movie I saw this year! 10/28/04 s4|nt you probobly think your artsy dont you? it blows 10/27/04 The Talking Elbow Left me feeling 'bleh' at the end. Lacks real substance, more style then anything. But good 10/23/04 Mikami Very sophisticated, non-linear film! 10/12/04 Laura Defininutly awesome!!!!! 10/08/04 Flounder Incredible 10/03/04 Doc Hollywood Thought provoking and evocative. 9/29/04 Flounder I'm absolutely stunned that I enjoyed this. 9/28/04 MikeC Best movie i've seen in a decade 9/24/04 Agent Sands One of the freshest, greatest movies in awhile. 9/22/04 brit this is an amazing film. it is more than just simple entertainment.rather it is an artwork! 9/22/04 nh great 8/14/04 Peter James The best films of the year 8/06/04 Terry Best film I've seen all year, or even the last couple 8/04/04 Elena Best screenplay and direction in ten years 8/01/04 Luna Pierce This movie has got to go on the top ten best movies of the year if not the last decade. 7/24/04 marcelo marques Briliantly made. K. takes us on a journey which will never be erased from our minds..... 7/21/04 dropdead Amazing! Best movie I've seen in a very long time! 7/17/04 legend Hands down the best film this year. Great movie. 7/08/04 Liz I loved this movie when I saw it. It was able to actually keep my attention the entire time 6/30/04 Mikey Crunt I love this film. I was the only person in this old-fashioned cinema. Only in the UK 6/11/04 Elena If you didn't like it, then you shouldn't have seen it because for what it is it's amazing 6/09/04 S.F. Slow in the begining. A film that atleast tries to be different. Worth a watch. 6/07/04 James Kustes One of 2004's best. Great soundtrack by ELO, Beck, and Jon Brion! 6/02/04 Iris Dementia Praecox If Kirsten Dunst hadn't done VIRGIN SUICIDES, this would be every cast member's worst film! 6/01/04 Norma Lehigh Woo fonvoulted cor turds! 6/01/04 Turtle Touching, bizarre, and yet strangest of all, very real. Viva Charlie Kaufman! 6/01/04 Sheila Evans ALONG CAME POLLY meets FATAL ATTRACTION meets 50 LAST DATES. 5/30/04 Edler The ending was a disaster... like they ran out of money and had to wrap up in a hurry. 5/27/04 Melissa P i loved the movie it's worth to see it, one of the few movies of its type that i enjoyed. 5/26/04 Proteus Amazing performances, compelling creative script, and directed with flair. A treasure. 5/22/04 Jackie Thomas original, great movie 5/20/04 Alan Liddle In my Top 10 - Very left field! 5/19/04 cpbjr One of the best movies I have seen in a long time. The story and its telling -- genius! 5/19/04 Agent Sands Extremely effective. It may be kinda confusing, but it kicks ass overall. 5/18/04 Elena Cloest thing to a perfect movie I've ever seen 5/17/04 JoeManco Each prayer accepted, and each wish resigned 5/15/04 steph an excellent film. really intresting and different ! loved it! :) 5/14/04 skye so glad kate wasn't drew b. nice movie, but getting tired of reality-manipulation gimmicary 5/14/04 earl duron WEIRD AND OVERATED=ANNOYING 5/11/04 Graham Great acting and script killed by gimmicky over-direction 5/11/04 Helen Bradley worst film of the decade 5/10/04 AR Utterly wonderful acting and filming; a beautiful concept as well. 5/10/04 Kimberly absolute genius 5/06/04 DM Hooray for Jim Carrey! Found a new character at last! 5/06/04 Mark Fulwiler Intelligent, well acted and entertaining 5/01/04 sulky Kaufman brilliant as ever, Gondry underrated, wonderful cast 5/01/04 Spud Envy Fabulous, funny, provocative and KIRSTEN DUNST in her undies!!! YOWZA 4/26/04 gabrielle amazing! cant stop thinking about it 4/26/04 Reini Urban Where Adapation failed, here it works. 4/24/04 lacondora great, weird, wonderful flick 4/23/04 Jorge Guimera heart and mind trip... a truly life experience 4/23/04 mccn22 great 4/22/04 ospinad simply put, best movie EVER! 4/21/04 Kathy Brilliant love story, heartbreaking and funny too, Best of 2004 so far 4/21/04 John Wallace long boring and confused 4/19/04 Rosie R Brilliant! 4/19/04 Marc Reasoner Bittersweet brilliance 4/19/04 T$ excellent 4/19/04 Boris Brilliant. Winslet is so adorable in this film, while Carrey holds his own. 4/19/04 Owen Earp Phenomenal film... Jim Carrey & Kate Winslet are both truly captivating. True storytelling. 4/19/04 Kevin c This movies sucks 4/19/04 Nipun Sareen Smashing! Just one of the movies you would like never to end !!!! 4/18/04 frankie stein deep and thought provoking. My new favorite movie 4/17/04 zeitgeist Brilliant. Kaufman is a 21st century Philip K. Dick with glitz 4/14/04 Agent Sands So deep it gets to boggle the mind into tying itself in knots, but it sure is great. 4/13/04 CB truly beautiful...congrats Kaufman 4/13/04 Aaron Artfully tasteful, but not great 4/11/04 Jessica awesome movie 4/10/04 Sean Anderson Has made me look at movies in a whole new light. One of my absolute favorites. 4/08/04 colleen beautiful. 4/08/04 Robert Wow, absolutely amazing. It'll mess with your head for a week 4/07/04 mason ok if you like watching multi-millionaires try to play "regular-folks", annoying soundtrack 4/06/04 re a great film 4/04/04 Kbar a bit overobvious of a plot...no true mindfuck here 4/02/04 Robert Goodwin Please tell everyone you know to go see this movie!!! Absolutely Incredible. 4/02/04 othree great & touched way i can't express, carey (rocked)& winslet = wonderful 2 4/01/04 Andy Lindsay Truly excellent. I'll see it again before it leaves the theaters. 3/31/04 Jessie i loved it! 3/31/04 Nicole Very solid movie, I was impressed. 3/29/04 Barrett A stunningly beautiful and human film. 3/29/04 jefftucson Best film I've seen in about a year. 3/29/04 chris. awesome...NOT terrific 3/28/04 FrayLo Takes a while to get started, but definitely relateable and compelling. 3/28/04 Margie very very good... i think most people can relate with the subject matter 3/27/04 average guy It's Worth a Look, but I was expecting too much after the buzz 3/27/04 Kristin Fantastically creative and touching as well. "Being John Malkovich" with heart. 3/27/04 Nathaniel No other word but amazing is needed 3/27/04 Alicia I usually avoid anything with Jim Carey, but give him an Oscar! 3/26/04 Melissa Gaugert Wonderful, surprising, sad, happy, funny --great all around movie! 3/25/04 Eric This movie is incredible... It really touched me because, basically, I AM Joel. 3/25/04 Emily When it was over i just sat there and took big breaths... 3/25/04 rojo Great movie, be patient. 3/24/04 Rich Great, thought provoking movie 3/24/04 rje I like Jim Carrey but this is the worst movie imaginable 3/23/04 Desperado Perfect, Incredible, I have seen a lot of movies, and this is one of my favorites, A+ 3/23/04 cobra commander pretty damn good job by carey... a bit magnolia'esque nonetheless... fantastic!! 3/23/04 Mortis Beautiful, engaging, engrossing, distrubing, saddening & uplifting - wonderfully acted 3/22/04 Jon Jabber incredible acting performances especially from carrey, dunst, and winslet 3/22/04 Mitch this film was really strange, and I don't think I got it. Mostly , it made me really sad. 3/22/04 A F This will be hard to beat this year!!! In my mind anyway. 3/21/04 Z_Fine The best film I have ever seen. 3/21/04 susan lee kaufman rules 3/21/04 midLI Cannot wait until I see it again! Better than awesome. 3/21/04 Bubba Jones What 'Punch Drunk Love' was supposed to be (without the hype, too) & more. 3/21/04 Koitus Parts were confusing, because of "jumbled" time-line(s); great flashbacks to childhood! 3/20/04 True Grit Memento is about ten times better. The actors were cool but the movie lead nowhere. 3/20/04 Titus Fantastic movie in every way. 3/19/04 john wonderful, clever as 'Momento, romance, love etc. 3/18/04 Cameron Slick An amazing, provactive, genius romantic comedy dreams are made of. 3/14/04 Ray Carrey is good, but it isnt that much a comedy

IF YOU'VE SEEN THIS FILM, RATE IT! Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks! Your Name: Your Comments: Your Location: (state/province/country) Your Rating: Select a rating from the list: 5 STARS - Awesome 4 STARS - Worth A Look 3 STARS - Just Average 2 STARS - Pretty Crappy 1 STAR - Sucks