Jamie Kennedy's favorite movie review site
Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 

Overall Rating

Awesome: 16.87%
Worth A Look: 16.87%
Just Average: 13.25%
Pretty Crappy30.12%
Sucks: 22.89%

7 reviews, 41 user ratings

Latest Reviews

Luxor by Peter Sobczynski

Wander by Peter Sobczynski

Love, Weddings & Other Disasters by Peter Sobczynski

Black Bear by Peter Sobczynski

Poison Rose, The by Jack Sommersby

Ma Rainey's Black Bottom by Jay Seaver

Fat Man and Little Boy by Jack Sommersby

Harry & Son by Jack Sommersby

Shattered by Jack Sommersby

Deathstalker II by Jack Sommersby

subscribe to this feed

Stay (2005)
[AllPosters.com] Buy posters from this movie
by Robert Flaxman

"Stay away."
2 stars

Have you ever seen a movie that wanted you to know its surprise going in? Neither had I, but apparently Stay is such a movie. The trailer makes the main characterís fate fairly clear, and director Marc Forster believes that the audience should know, going in, that the film is not set in reality. Between that and the car crash that opens the film, it should, in theory, be easy enough to figure out whatís going on.

What Forster and company donít seem to realize is that films with surprise endings tend to have them for a reason; the audience gets to try and guess what the resolution will be, and then can be surprised or not (if it was easy to divine). The problem with Stay is that it hangs around for 100 minutes even though itís already suggested to us how itís going to end.

Following the crash, we see Henry (Ryan Gosling) sitting next to his burning car. Eventually he gets up and walks off, and shortly thereafter we are introduced to Sam (Ewan McGregor), a psychiatrist who is taking over Henryís case. Henry announces that he is going to kill himself on Saturday at midnight.

Itís hard to discuss Stay because itís not clear what should remain a secret and what the filmmakers think people should know anyway. The unreality of the filmís setting is clearly some sort of limbo between life and death, and itís easy enough to guess that Henry is the character in that limbo Ė or is he? After all, Sam is the main character, and various scenes suggest that Sam and Henry may not even be different people.

In fact Ė as revealed by Forster in an interview on MTV.com Ė the limbo is really Henryís pre-death dream, and the characters in it are all aspects of himself, their appearances pulled from the people who show up at the scene of the accident (only revealed at the end of the film). Normally I would think that this shouldnít be mentioned in a review, but if even the director doesnít care, why should I?

Maybe thatís why no one went to see Stay Ė itís a movie that structures itself to have twists, but was made by people desperate to give those twists away before you walk into the theater. Really, what was the point of even making it the way Forster did? Itís possible to structure a film about death so that it isnít a surprise Ė one that jumps to mind is What Dreams May Come with Robin Williams, although of course that one wasnít a hit at the box office either Ė so why didnít Forster go down that road? Instead, he attempts to drag out the surprises. Why does Gosling claim that his parents are dead when they appear to be alive? Why do peopleís heads keep bleeding? Why are there sets of twins everywhere? Why do things keep repeating?

I suppose the idea is that the audience gets to try and figure these things out based on what it knows when it enters the theater. But if that was the intention, the structure of the film should have made things more clear. Instead, Forster strings us along, and anyone not lucky enough to hear his pronouncement is in the dark, with little sense for what is supposed to be going on and without the information necessary to really process it.

More problematically, there just isnít that much going on for most of Stay. Even while ostensibly presenting clues to the exact nature of its reality, the film is plodding and rarely compelling; the dialogue given to its characters is stunningly banal and often embarrassingly expository. Given where it goes, itís possible that this was an intentional move on the part of Forster and writer David Benioff (25th Hour), but that doesnít make it interesting or entertaining, especially if the director didnít warn you ahead of time.

Ultimately, Stay is too contradictory for its own good. It wants you to know what happens, but sets up as though itís going to surprise; it wants to be about Henryís trip to limbo, but doesnít have a lot of content there; it wants to be an examination of loss, but spends too much time on other angles. All told, thereís both too much going on in Stay and, at the same time, not nearly enough.

link directly to this review at https://www.hollywoodbitchslap.com/review.php?movie=13272&reviewer=385
originally posted: 11/12/05 22:26:22
[printer] printer-friendly format  

User Comments

6/30/11 iamhenry McGregor's pants were short because that's what happens when you crouch near a dying man 4 stars
10/23/09 darren Look at the film in reverse and it might make sense. It was a big Jacobs Ladder rip off 4 stars
12/14/08 g made no sense, especially the end 2 stars
12/04/08 Shaun Wallner This movie was stupid! 2 stars
4/13/08 Matt One of the best movies I've ever seen. And this critic has no idea what it's about. 5 stars
2/12/08 escapegoat Does anyone get that it's from the point of view of Henry? 5 stars
8/28/07 truth ok to watch once - but some shit just doesnt make any sense which ruins it for me until 3 stars
8/21/07 Matt This goes straight to the top of the "what the fuck was all that about" dungheap 1 stars
8/16/07 Joe Thomas Throughly confusing, but equally compelling. You really need to enjoy films to like this. 4 stars
8/10/07 Kim if u dnt like it, u dnt think much.im wit luke928 5 stars
6/17/07 Anna WTF? It had such a weird ending..but i still loved it because of the twists.. 5 stars
5/11/07 Max WTF it was all like Mumbo JImbo 3 stars
3/30/07 fools♫gold Just a bunch of camera tricks; I may be overrating (I think), but it's not TOO bad. 3 stars
2/10/07 Luke928 wow you shouldn't even be a critic, you completely missed the point of this movie 5 stars
10/16/06 Andy G. It's all B.S! Everything is not real! I ddin't even write this comment! 2 stars
10/15/06 Kim I thought it was beautiful 5 stars
9/30/06 High Voltage just how many dumb people there are 5 stars
9/24/06 karen macarthur very confusing, tho amazing! 5 stars
8/02/06 manda Great Film 5 stars
6/29/06 Ash This movie was really confusing, I expected better.. 3 stars
6/26/06 jessica WTF 2 stars
6/25/06 Tiffaney This movie is obviously was not made for those who lack the mental capacity to understand a 4 stars
5/29/06 Jeff Great camera shots and angles - story is not worth sitting through. 2 stars
5/14/06 Max This movie is just VERY poorly done, cheesy and not very well connected. 1 stars
4/13/06 ket A really interesting movie. 4 stars
1/29/06 Betsy S I thought it was terrible from beginning to end. Sterile environment and monotone acting. 1 stars
11/17/05 Candy Smith Bad and confusing movie 2 stars
11/01/05 Roy Smith The book is better. And there is no book. 1 stars
10/28/05 Michael Well worth a second viewing. 5 stars
10/26/05 Jimbo I wish someone would explain the plot to me - very confusing movie 4 stars
10/26/05 stella visually stunning and thoughful, a film with depth. naomi stands out from the cast. 5 stars
10/26/05 steandric a great film for the thinking viewers. naomi watts is impressive. 5 stars
10/26/05 jcjs humdinger, clever, visual / editing delight, wow acting, scenery, fun, engaging all the way 5 stars
10/25/05 PAG Interesting unusual story. Arty and pretentious, but sometimes that is good. 4 stars
10/25/05 Kathy Great filming, architecture, camera angle,lost story,made no sense 3 stars
10/24/05 DEEDeeDEEe STAY? (Away) 1 stars
10/23/05 Jenn Why can't anyone seem to figure out why Sam's pants were short??? So simple!!! 4 stars
10/22/05 Douglas MacDonald This is the worst piece of tripe ever produced: self-absorbed and ridiculous. LSD req'd. 1 stars
10/22/05 TMoe Interesting photographey, but a twisted plot without any clarity for the audience to grasp. 2 stars
10/21/05 pattonjr5 though no md, watts & the others can make you think...but only if you want to 5 stars
Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments
will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks!
Your Name:
Your Comments:
Your Location: (state/province/country)
Your Rating:

Discuss this movie in our forum

  21-Oct-2005 (R)
  DVD: 28-Mar-2006



Directed by
  Marc Forster

Written by
  David Benioff

  Ewan McGregor
  Naomi Watts
  Ryan Gosling
  Janeane Garofalo
  Bob Hoskins
  Kate Burton

Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 
Privacy Policy | | HBS Inc. |   
All data and site design copyright 1997-2017, HBS Entertainment, Inc.
Search for
reviews features movie title writer/director/cast