Jamie Kennedy's favorite movie review site
Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 

Overall Rating

Worth A Look: 17.02%
Just Average: 13.83%
Pretty Crappy: 22.34%
Sucks: 8.51%

6 reviews, 58 user ratings

Latest Reviews

Old Guard, The by Peter Sobczynski

Greyhound by Peter Sobczynski

Guest of Honour by Peter Sobczynski

Miss Fisher and the Crypt of Tears by Jay Seaver

Dealer/Healer by Jay Seaver

City Without Baseball by Jay Seaver

Invisible Man, The (2020) by Rob Gonsalves

Hunt, The (2020) by Rob Gonsalves

Da 5 Bloods by Rob Gonsalves

Hamilton by Peter Sobczynski

subscribe to this feed

But I'm a Cheerleader
[AllPosters.com] Buy posters from this movie
by Rob Gonsalves

"With 'friends' like this, gay moviegoers don't need enemies."
2 stars

In the self-consciously farcical 'But I'm a Cheerleader,' everyone thinks Natasha Lyonne is a lesbian, so she gets sent to a special camp ('True Directions') where young gay people are conditioned to be hetero. Does it work? No. The hetero-izing process, that is. Neither does the movie.

But I'm a Cheerleader tries way too hard to be a John Waters movie -- it's even got Waters regular Mink Stole as Natasha's mom. It's also trying too hard to be a cult comedy -- Bud Cort turns up as Natasha's dad, and the sight of Stole, Cort, and Lyonne at the dinner table (saying grace, yet) should be funkier than it is. Waters would've had a field day with this idea; so would Alexander Payne, whose satire would've been more even-handed.

Sounds like a promising premise, right? But the movie blows it by (A) trading in witless stereotypes and (B) not being remotely funny, despite the Roger Ebert blurb on the DVD box (was he on laughing gas or something?). A great comedy or drama could've been made about the whole "I Used to Be Gay Until I Turned to God" thing (an appalling real-life phenomenon), and this ain't it.

This is the kind of supposedly gay-friendly movie that traffics in stereotypes like whoa. The gay guys are your basic swishes, and the parents are uptight assholes without fail. The only group allowed to have some variety are the lesbians, who include Clea DuVall as a tomboy named Graham, Katharine Towne as a surly goth chick, Katrina Phillips as a butch jock, and Melanie Lynskey (Heavenly Creatures) as the sort of bashful girl she usually plays, only lesbian (she and Lyonne had just been in Detroit Rock City together). But really even the lesbians fall into generally recognized dyke stereotypes (although the dykiest one -- the butch jock -- turns out to be hetero after all). In all, it's another case of "dykes are chic, fags are funny."

We're encouraged to laugh at pretty much every instance of gay male identity (stereotyped or otherwise) we see. Example: Two former True Directions members, a gay couple named Larry and Lloyd Morgan-Gordon (Richard Moll and Wesley Mann), are sympathetic characters -- they take some of the kids out for a night at a gay club (called the Cocksucker, and show me the community that'd allow a club with that name within fifty miles of the town limits), and provide shelter for TD's outcasts. But they're still the standard-issue bickering gay couple, and even their hyphenated name is meant to be a joke.

Conversely, no particular lesbian traits come in for much goofing. During the kids' "gender identity training," the girls are competent enough at the housewife skills they're taught, whereas the gay boys are haplessly inept at football, car repair, cutting wood, etc., and are easily distracted by the camp supervisor's hunky son. This movie is basically for lesbians and for hetero women who enjoy gay men as sources of comfort and campy humor. Gay men may likely, and rightly, take the movie as a slap in the face.

Here's an example of the movie's meant-to-be-funny casting: RuPaul, in guy mode, plays one of TD's trainers. He makes his first appearance wearing a "Straight Is Great" T-shirt. (Didn't he notice how much fag-minstrelsy was in the script?) Cathy Moriarty is the camp supervisor, and her scenes with Lyonne have some potential for amusement given that the prematurely deep-voiced Lyonne is basically Moriarty 20 years ago, but instead you just note that Moriarty hasn't aged well and hope Lyonne has a better time of it.

How's Natasha in it? Weird. I mean, not intentionally, but seeing her being all cheerleader-y in this after seeing her scruffy riot-grrl performance in Confessions of a Trickbaby (aka Freeway 2) is ... well ... weird. I'm not sure she sells the cheerleader aspect -- they needed more of a bouncy Reese Witherspoon type, or Laura Dern 15 years ago -- but she's worth watching even when fundamentally miscast. Honestly, she would've been more believable in the Clea DuVall role, but then we'd lose DuVall in one of her better performances.

Lyonne and DuVall make a nice couple; their low-key acting styles mesh well, and when they start falling for each other their scenes together become candid, genuine, touching, and eventually erotic. They seem to be falling in love in a different movie from the one unfolding so goofily and broadly around them. Their love scenes are sensitively done and serious (whereas, again, the brief gay-male sexuality we see is fumbling and comical); the rest of the movie is irredeemably cartoonish.

Well, any movie with a cameo by Julie Delpy as a character credited as "Lipstick Lesbian" can't be all bad. Though it's a close call.

link directly to this review at https://www.hollywoodbitchslap.com/review.php?movie=4405&reviewer=416
originally posted: 12/28/06 20:00:05
[printer] printer-friendly format  

User Comments

3/17/16 Dane Youssef This really was a fun movie. A cut-and-notch above most schlocky formula Hollywood junk. 4 stars
12/20/08 Shaun Wallner Great story! 5 stars
11/02/08 Samantha Pruitt great camp, some funny parts, there are some great characters in this. 4 stars
8/18/06 Taylor Fladgate Not the best ending, but c'mon EricDSnider, it was good! 4 stars
6/14/06 Lisa Hilarious!! One of the campest films ever!!! 5 stars
2/06/06 Anthony How is this movie worth watching 1 stars
2/17/05 axe Has all the depth of Addams Family Values, but it was fun! 3 stars
6/25/04 MAB Loving it 5 stars
4/25/04 Cornelia Really cute 4 stars
10/15/03 Summer This is my favourite movie of all time. 5 stars
9/28/03 Anna it's so wonderful. I love "Graham" and the whole move! tanks for it! 5 stars
8/22/03 nr clea did great 5 stars
8/11/03 jen i liked it 4 stars
7/21/03 M. W. I love this movie! 5 stars
4/01/03 me great 5 stars
3/14/03 HE GREAT FILM 5 stars
3/07/03 y2mckay I could have sworn I wrote a review of this. Am I losing my mind? 3 stars
3/03/03 !! A GREAT FILM 5 stars
12/25/02 sarah m to reini urban: that's the point, she can't kiss. it's her first lesbian experience. 5 stars
11/15/02 Big Ted Natasha was hilarious! 3 stars
9/14/02 sally wally I LOVE CLEA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 5 stars
3/18/02 Michelle Kenobi Funny and Charming. 4 stars
12/16/01 Flagg_Blackstone Katherine's chacter rules. If she wasn't there I probably wouldn't have liked it. 5 stars
12/03/01 John The mere thought of that fat bitch in an orgasmic state gives me dry heaves 2 stars
11/29/01 Hum great sets, good ideas, bad acting 3 stars
9/07/01 Lindsay FUCKING AMAZING!!!!! I LOVE THIS MOVIE!!! CLEA DUVALL.... RRRRRRR!!!!!!!!! 5 stars
8/19/01 Reini Urban Nice setting, but she cannot kiss. Bad cast, however gay movies are always funny, pseudo ga 3 stars
8/18/01 jon i luved it 5 stars
8/10/01 Destiny ~_^ I must see it again! ~_^ 5 stars
8/08/01 melissa i'd have liked to see more of katherine towne (sinead...mmmm...), but it was still awesome! 5 stars
7/28/01 Rachel This movie was the She-IT! But I'ma Cheerleader is the greatest film, the greatest I say!!! 5 stars
7/04/01 r-chan (what? you thought I'd give you the REAL one?) Ho-hum. I'd heard that this movie was really great, but it kind of let me down. 4 stars
7/03/01 Alyce & Kate Andre Rocks!!!! Kick ass show!!! 5 stars
6/13/01 lauren i thought it was amazing, and so funny. i even cried. =) clea duvall is definitely hot 5 stars
6/12/01 laurawho7 Best Gay Flick yet!! 5 stars
5/26/01 Stacey This was an amazing movie! Being a lesbian myself I really connected with it! 5 stars
5/25/01 Bada Bing Crosby Thankfully clocks in under 90mins., even that was a struggle. UGH!! 1 stars
5/25/01 Max The best part is the beginning. All those succulent cheerleaders bouncing up and down. 3 stars
5/23/01 Jessica Koala I loved it... and I'm so happy that it was made .. it kicks big fucking ass!!! ;p 5 stars
4/24/01 Monday Morning Not just unfunny, but poorly produced and acted. Waste of time.. 1 stars
4/19/01 Stephen Booth Best film in a long time 5 stars
4/15/01 Candie Barnett It's cool 4 stars
4/08/01 Lindsay It had a really good plot and point, but had too many lame parts stuck in between. 4 stars
3/19/01 *~Danielle*Ophelia~* (formerly KyLe*BrOfLoVsKi) Bordering on ridiculous, but...it's all in the name of camp... 4 stars
3/12/01 Johnboy The lesbian scene was pretty cool, but it was all downhill from there 2 stars
2/20/01 Rocket Boy One-note joke gone an hour and a half too far. 1 stars
1/14/01 chris sucked really bad 1 stars
12/31/00 jen perfect film! great visuals, silly story and brill acting! 5 stars
11/20/00 neil bartlett great idea, but simply isn't funny 2 stars
10/15/00 The Bomb 69 biting satire, funny all the way through, good music as well 5 stars
10/13/00 Leon Trotsky The music puts it over the top. Too cool. 5 stars
10/09/00 Monday Morning This "satire" is lame...cinematography and acting are poor as well. 1 stars
8/25/00 Reverend Krule "Silly Faggot, Dicks are for Chicks" 5 stars
8/17/00 Ryan Phillippe Gets Hit By A Car and It Fuckin Rules! This movie was the most awesome thing that ever happened to me, before the labotomy. 5 stars
8/09/00 pipeman A great idea, but not enough to sustain the entire movie. I got bored. 3 stars
8/08/00 Phag Another case of beating satire to death and ending up with lots of crap 1 stars
8/03/00 Jake Very funny. Has its gay cliche spoofs in it. 5 stars
Note: Duplicate, 'planted,' or other obviously improper comments
will be deleted at our discretion. So don't bother posting 'em. Thanks!
Your Name:
Your Comments:
Your Location: (state/province/country)
Your Rating:

Discuss this movie in our forum

  28-Jul-2000 (R)


  16-Nov-2000 (MA)

Directed by
  Jamie Babbit

Written by
  Brian Wayne Peterson

  Natasha Lyonne
  Clea DuVall
  Cathy Moriarty
  Bud Cort
  Mink Stole

Home Reviews  Articles  Release Dates Coming Soon  DVD  Top 20s Criticwatch  Search
Public Forums  Festival Coverage  Contests About 
Privacy Policy | | HBS Inc. |   
All data and site design copyright 1997-2017, HBS Entertainment, Inc.
Search for
reviews features movie title writer/director/cast